|
1 |
|
2 <!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------> |
|
3 <table border=1 cellspacing=0 cellpadding=3 width=100%> |
|
4 <tr> |
|
5 <th bgcolor=DDDDDD width=8% rowspan=2> Metric </th> |
|
6 <th bgcolor=DDDDDD rowspan=2> Metric <br> components</th> |
|
7 <th bgcolor=DDDDDD rowspan=2> Observations & <br> comparison protocol</th> |
|
8 <th bgcolor=DDDDDD rowspan=2> Model<br> model1 </th> |
|
9 <th bgcolor=DDDDDD rowspan=2> Model<br> model2 </th> |
|
10 <th bgcolor=DDDDDD colspan=3> Score (points) </th> |
|
11 </tr> |
|
12 <tr> |
|
13 <th width=6% bgcolor=DDDDDD> Full </th> |
|
14 <th width=6% bgcolor=DDDDDD> model1 </th> |
|
15 <th width=6% bgcolor=DDDDDD> model2 </th> |
|
16 </tr> |
|
17 |
|
18 <tr> |
|
19 <th rowspan=6>NPP</th> |
|
20 |
|
21 <th rowspan=2>EMDI NPP <br> observations</th> |
|
22 |
|
23 <th> |
|
24 <a href=../model1/npp/table_site81_ob.html> |
|
25 Class_A_table</a> |
|
26 </th> |
|
27 |
|
28 <th> |
|
29 <a href=../model1/npp/table_site81_model_vs_ob.html> |
|
30 table</a> <br> |
|
31 <a href=../model1/npp/scatter_model_vs_ob_81.png> |
|
32 scatter_plot</a> |
|
33 </th> |
|
34 |
|
35 <th> |
|
36 <a href=../model2/npp/table_site81_model_vs_ob.html> |
|
37 table</a> <br> |
|
38 <a href=../model2/npp/scatter_model_vs_ob_81.png> |
|
39 scatter_plot</a> |
|
40 </th> |
|
41 |
|
42 <th>2.5</th> |
|
43 <th>M_npp_S81</th> |
|
44 <th>M_npp_S81</th> |
|
45 </tr> |
|
46 |
|
47 <tr> |
|
48 <th> |
|
49 <a href=../model1/npp/table_site933_ob.html> |
|
50 Class_B_table</a> |
|
51 </th> |
|
52 |
|
53 <th> |
|
54 <a href=../model1/npp/table_site933_model_vs_ob.html> |
|
55 table</a> <br> |
|
56 <a href=../model1/npp/scatter_model_vs_ob_933.png> |
|
57 scatter_plot</a> |
|
58 </th> |
|
59 |
|
60 <th> |
|
61 <a href=../model2/npp/table_site933_model_vs_ob.html> |
|
62 table</a> <br> |
|
63 <a href=../model2/npp/scatter_model_vs_ob_933.png> |
|
64 scatter_plot</a> |
|
65 </th> |
|
66 |
|
67 <th>2.5</th> |
|
68 <th>M_npp_S933</th> |
|
69 <th>M_npp_S933</th> |
|
70 </tr> |
|
71 |
|
72 <tr> |
|
73 <th rowspan=2>EMDI NPP <br> normalized by PPT</th> |
|
74 |
|
75 <th> |
|
76 <a href=../model1/npp/histogram_ob_81.png> |
|
77 Class_A_histogram</a> |
|
78 </th> |
|
79 |
|
80 <th> |
|
81 <a href=../model1/npp/histogram_model_vs_ob_81.png> |
|
82 Class_A_histogram</a> |
|
83 </th> |
|
84 |
|
85 <th> |
|
86 <a href=../model2/npp/histogram_model_vs_ob_81.png> |
|
87 Class_A_histogram</a> |
|
88 </th> |
|
89 |
|
90 <th>2.5</th> |
|
91 <th>M_npp_H81</th> |
|
92 <th>M_npp_H81</th> |
|
93 </tr> |
|
94 |
|
95 <tr> |
|
96 <th> |
|
97 <a href=../model1/npp/histogram_ob_933.png> |
|
98 Class_B_histogram</a> |
|
99 </th> |
|
100 |
|
101 <th> |
|
102 <a href=../model1/npp/histogram_model_vs_ob_933.png> |
|
103 Class_B_histogram</a> |
|
104 </th> |
|
105 |
|
106 <th> |
|
107 <a href=../model2/npp/histogram_model_vs_ob_933.png> |
|
108 Class_B_histogram</a> |
|
109 </th> |
|
110 |
|
111 <th>2.5</th> |
|
112 <th>M_npp_H933</th> |
|
113 <th>M_npp_H933</th> |
|
114 </tr> |
|
115 |
|
116 <tr> |
|
117 <th>Correlation with MODIS obs.</th> |
|
118 |
|
119 <th> |
|
120 <a href=../model1/npp/global_ob.png> |
|
121 global_map</a> |
|
122 </th> |
|
123 |
|
124 <th> |
|
125 <a href=../model1/npp/global_model.png> |
|
126 model_map</a> <br> |
|
127 <a href=../model1/npp/global_model_vs_ob.png> |
|
128 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
129 </th> |
|
130 |
|
131 <th> |
|
132 <a href=../model2/npp/global_model.png> |
|
133 model_map</a> <br> |
|
134 <a href=../model2/npp/global_model_vs_ob.png> |
|
135 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
136 </th> |
|
137 |
|
138 <th>5</th> |
|
139 <th>M_npp_G</th> |
|
140 <th>M_npp_G</th> |
|
141 </tr> |
|
142 |
|
143 <tr> |
|
144 <th>Correlation with MODIS-zonal mean</th> |
|
145 |
|
146 <th> |
|
147 <a href=../model1/npp/zonal_ob.png> |
|
148 zonal_mean_obs</a> |
|
149 </th> |
|
150 |
|
151 <th> |
|
152 <a href=../model1/npp/zonal_model_vs_ob.png> |
|
153 zonal_mean <br> model_vs_obs_plot</a> |
|
154 </th> |
|
155 |
|
156 <th> |
|
157 <a href=../model2/npp/zonal_model_vs_ob.png> |
|
158 zonal_mean <br> model_vs_obs_plot</a> |
|
159 </th> |
|
160 |
|
161 <th>5</th> |
|
162 <th>M_npp_Z</th> |
|
163 <th>M_npp_Z</th> |
|
164 </tr> |
|
165 |
|
166 <tr> |
|
167 <th rowspan=3>LAI</th> |
|
168 |
|
169 <th>MODIS Mean</th> |
|
170 |
|
171 <th> |
|
172 <a href=../model1/lai/global_class_ob.png> |
|
173 land_class_obs</a> <br> |
|
174 <a href=../model1/lai/global_class_model.png> |
|
175 land_class_model</a> <br> |
|
176 <a href=../model1/lai/global_Mean_ob.png> |
|
177 global_map</a> |
|
178 </th> |
|
179 |
|
180 <th> |
|
181 <a href=../model1/lai/table_model_vs_ob.html> |
|
182 model_vs_obs_table</a> <br> |
|
183 <a href=../model1/lai/global_Mean_model.png> |
|
184 global_map</a> <br> |
|
185 <a href=../model1/lai/global_Mean_model_vs_ob.png> |
|
186 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
187 </th> |
|
188 |
|
189 <th> |
|
190 <a href=../model2/lai/table_model_vs_ob.html> |
|
191 model_vs_obs_table</a> <br> |
|
192 <a href=../model2/lai/global_Mean_model.png> |
|
193 global_map</a> <br> |
|
194 <a href=../model2/lai/global_Mean_model_vs_ob.png> |
|
195 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
196 </th> |
|
197 |
|
198 <th>5</th> |
|
199 <th>M_lai_Mean</th> |
|
200 <th>M_lai_Mean</th> |
|
201 </tr> |
|
202 |
|
203 <tr> |
|
204 <th>MODIS Maximum</th> |
|
205 |
|
206 <th> |
|
207 <a href=../model1/lai/global_Max_ob.png> |
|
208 global_map</a> |
|
209 </th> |
|
210 |
|
211 <th> |
|
212 <a href=../model1/lai/global_Max_model.png> |
|
213 global_map</a> <br> |
|
214 <a href=../model1/lai/global_Max_model_vs_ob.png> |
|
215 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
216 </th> |
|
217 |
|
218 <th> |
|
219 <a href=../model2/lai/global_Max_model.png> |
|
220 global_map</a> <br> |
|
221 <a href=../model2/lai/global_Max_model_vs_ob.png> |
|
222 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
223 </th> |
|
224 |
|
225 <th>5</th> |
|
226 <th>M_lai_Max</th> |
|
227 <th>M_lai_Max</th> |
|
228 </tr> |
|
229 <tr> |
|
230 <th>MODIS Phase</th> |
|
231 |
|
232 <th> |
|
233 <a href=../model1/lai/global_Phase_ob.png> |
|
234 global_map</a> |
|
235 </th> |
|
236 |
|
237 <th> |
|
238 <a href=../model1/lai/global_Phase_model.png> |
|
239 global_map</a> <br> |
|
240 <a href=../model1/lai/global_Phase_model_vs_ob.png> |
|
241 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
242 </th> |
|
243 |
|
244 <th> |
|
245 <a href=../model2/lai/global_Phase_model.png> |
|
246 global_map</a> <br> |
|
247 <a href=../model2/lai/global_Phase_model_vs_ob.png> |
|
248 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
249 </th> |
|
250 |
|
251 <th>5</th> |
|
252 <th>M_lai_Phase</th> |
|
253 <th>M_lai_Phase</th> |
|
254 </tr> |
|
255 |
|
256 <tr> |
|
257 <th>CO2<br> Seasonal<br> Cycle</th> |
|
258 <th>Comparison with NOAA observations <br> phase and amplitude</th> |
|
259 <th>--</th> |
|
260 |
|
261 <th> |
|
262 <a href=../model1/co2/score+line_vs_ob.html> |
|
263 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
264 </th> |
|
265 |
|
266 <th> |
|
267 <a href=../model2/co2/score+line_vs_ob.html> |
|
268 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
269 </th> |
|
270 |
|
271 <th>20</th> |
|
272 <th>M_co2</th> |
|
273 <th>M_co2</th> |
|
274 </tr> |
|
275 |
|
276 <tr> |
|
277 <th rowspan=2>Carbon<br> Stocks</th> |
|
278 |
|
279 <th>Aboveground live biomass <br> in South America</th> |
|
280 |
|
281 <th> |
|
282 <a href=../model1/biomass/global_ob.png> |
|
283 obs_amazon</a> |
|
284 </th> |
|
285 |
|
286 <th> |
|
287 <a href=../model1/biomass/global_model.png> |
|
288 model_amazon</a> <br> |
|
289 <a href=../model1/biomass/global_model_vs_ob.png> |
|
290 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
291 </th> |
|
292 |
|
293 <th> |
|
294 <a href=../model2/biomass/global_model.png> |
|
295 amazon_map</a> <br> |
|
296 <a href=../model2/biomass/global_model_vs_ob.png> |
|
297 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
298 </th> |
|
299 |
|
300 <th>5</th> |
|
301 <th>M_biomass</th> |
|
302 <th>M_biomass</th> |
|
303 </tr> |
|
304 |
|
305 <tr> |
|
306 <th>Aboveground live <br> biomass <br> within Amazon Basin <br>(sum within Legal Amazon)</th> |
|
307 <th> |
|
308 <a href=../model1/biomass/mask_ob.png> |
|
309 mask</a> <br> |
|
310 <a href=../model1/biomass/global_mask_ob.png> |
|
311 obs_masked</a> <br> |
|
312 Sum_biomass_ob (Pg C) |
|
313 </th> |
|
314 |
|
315 <th> |
|
316 <a href=../model1/biomass/global_mask_model.png> |
|
317 model_masked</a> <br> |
|
318 <a href=../model1/biomass/global_mask_vs_ob.png> |
|
319 model_vs_obs</a> <br> |
|
320 Sum_biomass_mod (Pg C) |
|
321 </th> |
|
322 |
|
323 <th> |
|
324 <a href=../model2/biomass/global_mask_model.png> |
|
325 model_masked</a> <br> |
|
326 <a href=../model2/biomass/global_mask_vs_ob.png> |
|
327 model_vs_obs</a> <br> |
|
328 Sum_biomass_mod (Pg C) |
|
329 </th> |
|
330 |
|
331 <th>5</th> |
|
332 <th>M_biomask</th> |
|
333 <th>M_biomask</th> |
|
334 </tr> |
|
335 |
|
336 <tr> |
|
337 <th rowspan=4>Energy and<br>C Fluxes<br>from Fluxnet</th> |
|
338 |
|
339 <th>NEE</th> |
|
340 |
|
341 <th rowspan=4> |
|
342 <a href=../model1/fluxnet/line_ob.html> |
|
343 line_plot</a> |
|
344 </th> |
|
345 |
|
346 <th rowspan=4> |
|
347 <a href=../model1/fluxnet/score+line_vs_ob.html> |
|
348 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
349 </th> |
|
350 |
|
351 <th rowspan=4> |
|
352 <a href=../model2/fluxnet/score+line_vs_ob.html> |
|
353 model_vs_obs</a> |
|
354 </th> |
|
355 |
|
356 <th>5</th> |
|
357 <th>M_fluxnet_nee</th> |
|
358 <th>M_fluxnet_nee</th> |
|
359 </tr> |
|
360 |
|
361 <tr> |
|
362 <th>Net radiation</th> |
|
363 <th>5</th> |
|
364 <th>M_fluxnet_rad</th> |
|
365 <th>M_fluxnet_rad</th> |
|
366 </tr> |
|
367 |
|
368 <tr> |
|
369 <th>Latent heat</th> |
|
370 <th>5</th> |
|
371 <th>M_fluxnet_lh</th> |
|
372 <th>M_fluxnet_lh</th> |
|
373 </tr> |
|
374 |
|
375 <tr> |
|
376 <th>Sensible heat</th> |
|
377 <th>5</th> |
|
378 <th>M_fluxnet_sh</th> |
|
379 <th>M_fluxnet_sh</th> |
|
380 </tr> |
|
381 |
|
382 <tr> |
|
383 <th rowspan=6>Energy and<br>C Fluxes<br>from Ameriflux</th> |
|
384 |
|
385 <th>NEE</th> |
|
386 |
|
387 <th rowspan=6> |
|
388 <a href=../model1/ameriflux/line_ob.html> |
|
389 line_plot</a> |
|
390 </th> |
|
391 |
|
392 <th rowspan=6> |
|
393 <a href=../model1/ameriflux/score+line_vs_ob.html> |
|
394 model_vs_obs</a> <br> |
|
395 <a href=../model1/ameriflux/tseries_vs_ob.html> |
|
396 timeseries_plot</a> |
|
397 </th> |
|
398 |
|
399 <th rowspan=6> |
|
400 <a href=../model2/ameriflux/score+line_vs_ob.html> |
|
401 model_vs_obs</a> <br> |
|
402 <a href=../model2/ameriflux/tseries_vs_ob.html> |
|
403 timeseries_plot</a> |
|
404 </th> |
|
405 |
|
406 <th>1</th> |
|
407 <th>M_ameriflux_nee</th> |
|
408 <th>M_ameriflux_nee</th> |
|
409 </tr> |
|
410 |
|
411 <tr> |
|
412 <th>Shortwave Incoming</th> |
|
413 <th>1</th> |
|
414 <th>M_ameriflux_rad</th> |
|
415 <th>M_ameriflux_rad</th> |
|
416 </tr> |
|
417 |
|
418 <tr> |
|
419 <th>Latent heat</th> |
|
420 <th>1</th> |
|
421 <th>M_ameriflux_lh</th> |
|
422 <th>M_ameriflux_lh</th> |
|
423 </tr> |
|
424 |
|
425 <tr> |
|
426 <th>Sensible heat</th> |
|
427 <th>1</th> |
|
428 <th>M_ameriflux_sh</th> |
|
429 <th>M_ameriflux_sh</th> |
|
430 </tr> |
|
431 |
|
432 <tr> |
|
433 <th>GPP</th> |
|
434 <th>1</th> |
|
435 <th>M_ameriflux_gpp</th> |
|
436 <th>M_ameriflux_gpp</th> |
|
437 </tr> |
|
438 |
|
439 <tr> |
|
440 <th>ER</th> |
|
441 <th>1</th> |
|
442 <th>M_ameriflux_er</th> |
|
443 <th>M_ameriflux_er</th> |
|
444 </tr> |
|
445 |
|
446 <tr> |
|
447 <th rowspan=4>Transient Dynamics</th> |
|
448 <th>Beta factor for NPP Stimulation from elevated CO2</th> |
|
449 <th>--</th> |
|
450 |
|
451 <th> |
|
452 <a href=../model1/beta/table_station.html> |
|
453 FACE_Site_comparison</a> <br> |
|
454 <a href=../model1/beta/table_biome.html> |
|
455 biome_table</a> |
|
456 </th> |
|
457 |
|
458 <th> |
|
459 <a href=../model2/beta/table_station.html> |
|
460 FACE_Site_comparison</a> <br> |
|
461 <a href=../model2/beta/table_biome.html> |
|
462 biome_table</a> |
|
463 </th> |
|
464 |
|
465 <th>3</th> |
|
466 <th>M_beta</th> |
|
467 <th>M_beta</th> |
|
468 </tr> |
|
469 |
|
470 <tr> |
|
471 <th>Turnover times and pool sizes</th> |
|
472 <th>--</th> |
|
473 |
|
474 <th> |
|
475 <a href=../model1/turnover/table_Leaf.html> |
|
476 Leaf</a> <br> |
|
477 <a href=../model1/turnover/table_Wood.html> |
|
478 Wood</a> <br> |
|
479 <a href=../model1/turnover/table_Fine_Root.html> |
|
480 Fine_Root</a> <br> |
|
481 <a href=../model1/turnover/table_Litter.html> |
|
482 Litter</a> <br> |
|
483 <a href=../model1/turnover/table_Coarse_Woody_Debris.html> |
|
484 Coarse_Woody_Debris</a> <br> |
|
485 <a href=../model1/turnover/table_Soil.html> |
|
486 Soil</a> |
|
487 </th> |
|
488 |
|
489 <th> |
|
490 <a href=../model2/turnover/table_Leaf.html> |
|
491 Leaf</a> <br> |
|
492 <a href=../model2/turnover/table_Wood.html> |
|
493 Wood</a> <br> |
|
494 <a href=../model2/turnover/table_Fine_Root.html> |
|
495 Fine_Root</a> <br> |
|
496 <a href=../model2/turnover/table_Litter.html> |
|
497 Litter</a> <br> |
|
498 <a href=../model2/turnover/table_Coarse_Woody_Debris.html> |
|
499 Coarse_Woody_Debris</a> <br> |
|
500 <a href=../model2/turnover/table_Soil.html> |
|
501 Soil</a> |
|
502 </th> |
|
503 |
|
504 <th>3</th> |
|
505 <th>--</th> |
|
506 <th>--</th> |
|
507 </tr> |
|
508 |
|
509 <tr> |
|
510 <th>Carbon Sinks<br>(1990-2004)</th> |
|
511 <th>--</th> |
|
512 |
|
513 <th> |
|
514 <a href=../model1/carbon_sink/table_per_m2.html> |
|
515 biome_mean</a> <br> |
|
516 <a href=../model1/carbon_sink/table_per_biome.html> |
|
517 biome_total</a> |
|
518 </th> |
|
519 |
|
520 <th> |
|
521 <a href=../model2/carbon_sink/table_per_m2.html> |
|
522 biome_mean</a> <br> |
|
523 <a href=../model2/carbon_sink/table_per_biome.html> |
|
524 biome_total</a> |
|
525 </th> |
|
526 |
|
527 <th>2</th> |
|
528 <th>--</th> |
|
529 <th>--</th> |
|
530 </tr> |
|
531 |
|
532 <tr> |
|
533 <th>Fire Variability</th> |
|
534 <th>--</th> |
|
535 |
|
536 <th> |
|
537 <a href=../model1/fire/global_model_vs_ob.png> |
|
538 global_spatial_comparison</a> <br> |
|
539 <a href=../model1/fire/table_fire.html> |
|
540 temporal_dynamics_(1997-2004)</a> |
|
541 </th> |
|
542 |
|
543 <th>--</th> |
|
544 |
|
545 <th>2</th> |
|
546 <th>M_fire</th> |
|
547 <th>--</th> |
|
548 </tr> |
|
549 |
|
550 <tr> |
|
551 <th bgcolor=DDDDDD> Total </th> |
|
552 <th colspan=4> </th> |
|
553 <th bgcolor=DDDDDD>100</th> |
|
554 <th bgcolor=DDDDDD>M_total</th> |
|
555 <th bgcolor=DDDDDD>M_total</th> |
|
556 </tr> |
|
557 |
|
558 </table> |
|
559 <!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------> |